If you’ve ever lost hours to a payroll spreadsheet, panicked over a missed tax deadline, or wondered if your multistate filings were compliant—you’re not alone. I’ve worked with hundreds of companies over the past 14 years, and the story is always the same: payroll starts out manageable, then grows into a time-consuming, risk-prone responsibility that distracts your team from more strategic goals.

That’s why 2025 is the year more companies—especially those with remote or hybrid teams—are choosing to outsource key payroll functions.

When done right, payroll outsourcing doesn’t just reduce administrative burden; it protects your business from costly mistakes and regulatory fallout. Here are the top 7 payroll tasks you should be outsourcing this year to simplify operations and stay compliant without the stress.

1. Payroll Tax Filing and Reporting

Federal, state, and local payroll taxes are complicated—and the rules are constantly changing. If you’re operating across state lines or have remote workers, it’s even trickier.

Outsourcing your payroll tax filings ensures:

• Timely deposits for FICA, FUTA, and SUTA
• Accurate filing of quarterly and annual forms (941, 940, W-2, etc.)
• Automatic calculation of local and multi-state withholding rates
• Avoidance of penalties from missed deadlines or incorrect forms

This is one of the most common (and valuable) tasks I take off clients’ plates—and where we save them the most in avoided IRS notices.

2. Employee Pay Processing

Whether you pay bi-weekly or semi-monthly, payroll runs demand precision. An outsourced payroll provider handles:

• Calculating gross pay, deductions, and net pay
• Managing direct deposit and paper check options
• Issuing off-cycle or bonus payments
• Managing garnishments or wage assignments

By outsourcing, you reduce errors, ensure consistency, and improve employee satisfaction through faster, more reliable payments.

3. Year-End Payroll Prep

Closing out the year isn’t just about sending W-2s. It’s about reconciling pay records, checking for errors, and preparing for audits or tax season.

A good payroll partner will:

• Automatically generate and file W-2s and 1099s
• Handle e-filing with the IRS and state agencies
• Provide employee access to digital copies
• Flag discrepancies before they become compliance issues

Trust me—this is a task you don’t want to leave until December.

4. New Hire Reporting and Onboarding Payroll Setup

Every state requires employers to report new hires—and the timeline is usually just a few days. Outsourced providers take care of:

• Registering new employees with the proper agencies
• Setting up payroll records with correct tax withholding
• Ensuring eligibility through I-9 and SSN verification tools
• Coordinating payroll schedules with start dates

When onboarding goes wrong, it’s usually because someone missed a detail. Letting a specialist handle it protects you from future headaches.

5. Multi-State Payroll Compliance

The growth of remote work has made multi-state compliance one of the biggest pain points for HR and finance teams. Each state has its own rules around taxes, wage laws, and employment registration.

Outsourcing ensures:

• Employees are properly registered in each state
• Local tax withholding is accurate
• State-specific wage notices and posters are delivered
• Employer tax accounts are opened and maintained properly

This is where businesses get blindsided the most—and where outsourcing provides an immediate ROI in risk reduction.

6. PTO Tracking and Time-Off Payouts

Paid time off seems simple—until it’s not. Managing accruals, carryovers, usage caps, and final payouts requires precision, especially if you operate in states with strict PTO payout laws.

Your payroll provider can:

• Automate PTO accrual and tracking
• Integrate with your timekeeping software
• Calculate final paychecks with unused time included
• Stay compliant with state-mandated time-off payout rules

One incorrect final paycheck can trigger a wage claim. Let the experts keep it clean.

7. Payroll Recordkeeping and Audit Support

Federal law requires employers to retain payroll records for at least three years—and sometimes longer, depending on the type of record. In the event of an audit or lawsuit, your documentation is your best defense.

Outsourced payroll teams help:

• Maintain secure, cloud-based payroll records
• Ensure required retention timelines are met
• Organize records by employee and pay cycle
• Provide fast access during audits or disputes

It’s one of those “behind-the-scenes” tasks that won’t matter—until it really does.

Now That You Know Why You Should Outsource Payroll Tasks, Here’s How to Get Started

Making the decision to outsource payroll is one thing—actually doing it is another. I’ve helped countless business owners make this shift over the years, and the process is always smoother when you know what to expect from the start. Here’s how to get started with confidence.

Start by Identifying Your Payroll Pain Points

The first step is a simple, honest evaluation of where your current payroll process is breaking down.

Are tax filings becoming stressful every quarter? Do you find yourself double-checking spreadsheets at midnight before payday? Are there complaints about pay accuracy or late checks? These are signs you’ve outgrown your current system.

Think about what tasks take the most time or keep you up at night. That’s where outsourcing can give you the greatest relief and return.

Decide What You Want to Hand Off—and What You Want to Keep

You don’t need to hand over your entire payroll function on day one. Many of my clients start by outsourcing just tax filings and direct deposit, then expand to include things like onboarding support or PTO tracking once they see how much time they’re saving.

If your business operates in multiple states or has complex benefit deductions, a full-service payroll provider might be the best route. But if you’re looking for more flexibility, choose a partner that allows you to keep control over certain tasks.

The key is to build a setup that supports your team, not overwhelms it.

Do a Careful Comparison of Payroll Providers

Once you know what you need, start comparing service providers. This part takes time—but it’s absolutely worth it.

Look for a provider with experience serving businesses similar to yours, whether that’s based on size, industry, or workforce type. Pay attention to how they price their services—some include everything in one monthly fee, while others charge per feature or per employee.

Just as important: evaluate their customer service. Ask if you’ll get a dedicated payroll rep or be routed through a call center. Your provider should feel like a partner, not just a software tool.

Ask the Right Questions During Onboarding

Once you’ve chosen a provider, the onboarding process will determine how smoothly the transition goes. Don’t assume anything—ask the questions that matter.

Clarify who’s responsible for tax registrations in each state where you have employees. Find out how often reports are shared and what your role will be in approving payroll. Make sure you know how they handle tax errors or late filings—and whether they’ll represent you if there’s a penalty.

Understanding these things early helps prevent surprises down the road.

Designate a Point Person Internally

Even with outsourced payroll, someone on your team should act as the primary contact for approvals, questions, and any time-sensitive changes. This person doesn’t need to be an HR expert—but they do need to stay organized and looped into the payroll calendar.

This keeps the partnership running smoothly and ensures nothing slips through the cracks, especially around onboarding or employee changes.

Trust the Process, but Don’t Disengage Completely

Outsourcing doesn’t mean disappearing from the process. It means leaning on experts while staying connected to what matters.

A good payroll provider will do the heavy lifting. But your insight, timing, and oversight still play a role. With that balance in place, payroll can become one of the most efficient parts of your business—not a constant source of stress.

Ready to Make the Switch?

If you’re serious about saving time, staying compliant, and improving the payroll experience for your team, outsourcing isn’t just an option—it’s the next smart move.

Whether you need a full-service solution or a few critical tasks off your plate, the right partner can help you get there faster and with less risk.

Let the Experts Handle the Stress

Outsourcing payroll isn’t just about saving time (though it absolutely will). It’s about protecting your business from risk, streamlining complexity, and allowing your internal team to focus on growth—not admin.

In 2025, payroll is more than just a line item. It’s an operational engine tied to employee experience, compliance, and strategic finance. Whether you’re running a 10-person team or a 200-person workforce, there’s a smarter way to handle it—and outsourcing the right tasks is where it starts.

—

Written by Kim Anderson, a Harvard University graduate with a bachelor’s degree in accounting and finance. I’m the owner of a successful payroll outsourcing company in California and a contributing writer for My Payroll Outsourcing. With 14 years of experience, I help businesses streamline payroll compliance, reduce administrative risk, and manage multi-state workforces with ease.